How to Conduct a Probation Review: Steps and Criteria

A probation review decides whether a new employee is confirmed, given more time or let go. Too often it is a signature on a form the week after probation has already ended. This guide shows how to run it properly: goals agreed at joining, short check-ins along the way, a rating against criteria the employee knew about, a meeting that explains the outcome, and a decision recorded before the probation end date.

Set the yardstick at joining

An employee can only be judged fairly against expectations they knew. In the first two weeks, the manager writes three to five probation goals and shares them. Take a new relationship executive at a Lucknow bank branch. Goals: finish the product certification within 30 days, handle walk-in customer queries independently by day 60, no KYC errors in the monthly audit sample, and attendance within policy. Each goal has a way to check it, so the review becomes a look at evidence rather than a matter of opinion.

Check in at 30 and 60 days

Two short check-ins, of about twenty minutes each, change the outcome of many probations. The manager says what is going well and what is not, with examples, and agrees what needs to change. The employee raises what is getting in the way, such as missing training or unclear targets. Both sides leave with notes. If the final review brings a surprise, the check-ins did not happen or were not honest.

Rating criteria that are fair

Use the same criteria for everyone in the same role and a scale with anchors, so two managers mean the same thing by a 3. A simple 1 to 5 scale works: 5 well above expectations, 3 meets expectations, 1 well below. Agree a decision rule in advance. For example, an average of 3 or more with no criterion at 1 means confirm; a specific, fixable gap means consider an extension; a clear shortfall or a conduct issue means not confirmed.

Probation goals met, with evidence
Quality and accuracy of work
Speed of learning the role and systems
Attendance and punctuality, from records
Conduct, teamwork and customer behaviour
Fit with the requirements of the role as offered

The review meeting

Hold the meeting before the probation end date, in private. Ask the employee for their view first, then share your assessment criterion by criterion with examples. State the outcome clearly. If the outcome is an extension or non-confirmation, have HR in the room. Send a written summary within a day with the outcome, the reasons and the next steps. Avoid rating on personality, comparing the employee with a previous holder of the role, or deciding after the end date has passed.

Step by step

Agree probation goals in week two. Write three to five goals with a way to check each, and share them with the employee. In ZeniaHR, set up a probation review cycle and add the goals as KPI, KRA or task, each with a weight.
Hold check-ins at day 30 and day 60. Spend twenty minutes on what is going well, what is not and what needs to change. Record short notes and share them with the employee.
Start the final review early. Begin three to four weeks before the end date. ZeniaHR's probation queue lists employees whose probation ends soon, overdue first, and sends daily reminders to HR and the manager.
Gather the evidence. Collect goal results, attendance records, quality checks, customer feedback and check-in notes before rating anyone.
Rate each criterion. Score each criterion on the anchored scale and write one line of evidence for each. In ZeniaHR, managers rate probation reviews from 1 to 5 with a comment in My Team.
Meet the employee. Hear their view first, walk through the ratings with examples and state the outcome. Bring HR in for extensions and non-confirmations.
Record the decision before the end date. Confirm, extend or record not confirmed before probation ends, so the employee is never left without a decision.
Issue the letter. Send the confirmation, extension or non-confirmation letter within a few days of the meeting and keep a copy on the employee's file.

Probation and confirmation Performance

See it on your own data

A 30-minute demo on a video call. We set up your departments, shifts and leave rules and show attendance, leave and payroll running for your team. Free for your first 50 employees.

Book a free demo See pricing

Frequently asked questions

What is a probation review?

A probation review is the assessment at the end of a new employee's probation period that decides whether they are confirmed, given an extension or not confirmed. It compares the employee's work, attendance and conduct with goals and criteria set at joining, and ends with a meeting and a written outcome.

When should a probation review be done?

Start the final review three to four weeks before the probation end date and finish it, including the meeting and the decision, before that date. Hold shorter check-ins at about 30 and 60 days so the employee has feedback and time to improve before the final review.

What criteria should a probation review use?

Use criteria tied to the job: the probation goals agreed at joining, quality and accuracy of work, speed of learning, attendance and punctuality, and conduct with colleagues and customers. Rate each on an anchored scale with one line of evidence, and use the same criteria for everyone in the same role.

Can an employee be confirmed automatically if no review is done?

Some companies confirm by default when the end date passes, and some HR systems, ZeniaHR included, offer an optional auto-confirm. It is safer to require a manager review for every probationer, because automatic confirmation can confirm someone whose problems were never discussed, and the notice period usually changes on confirmation.